Comparing sizing methods

Put the sizing methods side by side and choose one that fits your strategy and tolerance for drawdowns.

All courses · Lesson 9 of 10 · Intermediate · 3 min

Each sizing method answers the same question, how much to risk next, in a different way. This lesson puts them side by side so you can pick one for your own strategy and tolerance for drawdowns.

The five methods side by side

How each method behaves
MethodRisk after lossesRisk after winsComplexityMain danger
Fixed amountSame amount (a larger % of equity)Same amount (a smaller % of equity)Very lowNo compounding; the % risk rises in drawdowns
PercentageFalls with equityRises with equityLowA percentage that is too high for the strategy
Kelly (fractional)Falls with equity; depends on estimated W and RRises with equityMediumEstimation error; full Kelly gives huge swings
MartingaleMultiplied (for example 2×)Back to baseLowExponential growth of risk; ruin on a long streak
QuantRaider (adaptive)Reduced mildly by 10-trade momentumRaised by momentumMediumMore risk after lucky streaks; extra parameters to overfit

Same trades, different results

Worked example

Loss, loss, win with a reward-to-risk of 1

  1. Start with €10,000. Fixed risks €100: 9,900, then 9,800, then a win of €100 gives 9,900.
  2. Percentage risks 1%: 9,900, then 9,801, then a win of €98.01 gives 9,899.01.
  3. Martingale (base €100, 2×): 9,900, then a €200 loss gives 9,700, then a €400 win gives 10,100.

Martingale ends €200 ahead of the others on this three-trade sample, yet it needed a €400 stake; one more loss would have made the gap very different.

A short sample like this says nothing about long-run behaviour. The drawdowns and the largest stake matter at least as much as the final value.

How to choose

  • Start from the maximum drawdown you could tolerate, then pick the risk level at which a plausible losing streak stays within it.
  • Use fixed or percentage sizing for a new or untested strategy, because they need no estimate of your edge.
  • Consider a fraction of Kelly only after a large sample, and expect the estimate to move.
  • Treat martingale as a hazard, not as an option for accounts you cannot afford to lose.
  • Test any adaptive rule against plain percentage risk on the same trades, with the same costs.

Key takeaways

  • The methods differ in how risk responds to wins and losses, in complexity and in their main danger.
  • Choose by the drawdown you can tolerate and the evidence you have, not by the highest final value in a simulation.
  • Fixed and percentage sizing are the simplest starting points; Kelly and adaptive rules add estimates and parameters.
  • Compare any method on your own trades before relying on it.

Sign in to save your progress and quiz results.